The Protective vs. The Punitive Use of Force and 3 Strategies to Try

I was sitting with competing emotions recently--feeling peace and joy regarding the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday for those of us in the US, and conversely, feeling a lot of dread and hopelessness surrounding the increasing violence not only in the Middle East but in regions all across the globe.  I found myself wondering "Is violence ever justified?" You may be surprised to find out that indeed, sometimes force is exactly what is needed.

I’ve been sitting with competing emotions recently – feeling some peace and joy about the rest ahead for me during our upcoming Thanksgiving long weekend here in US, and at the same time, noticing so much ambient dread and hopelessness in me, connected to the increasing violence not only in the Middle East but in regions all around the globe. 

I found myself wondering “Is violence ever justified?”
Perhaps you’ve been wondering something similar.  

In my deep quest for a world that works for all people, combined with my desire for peace and the alleviation of suffering and oppression for all people, I can’t help but wonder:


What about those people who seek out war and actually enjoy inflicting suffering upon others?  What do we do about them?

In this week’s episode, I depart a bit from our usual format. Instead of responding to questions from the Conversations from the Heart Wednesday morning call, this “solo” episode is dedicated to exploring how the protective use of force differs from the punitive use of force in both intention and consequence.

In addition to discussing the differences between these two different types of force, I also offer up three practical, on-the-ground tools we can use (starting right now) to decrease our addiction to the punitive use of force and instead practice more life-affirming strategies in our daily lives. 

If you’d like to jump straight to those three tips, you can find the show notes below.  Interested in listening to the entire podcast?  Listen to the entire (20ish minutes) here.

Show notes:
[0:00] Intro
[2:45] The first line of defense in conflict management
[4:25] When is the use of force necessary?
[5:58] The intention behind the protective use of force
[6:30] The intention behind the punitive use of force
[8:08] The quickest way to reduce all violence
[10:40] The cost of submission
[12:45] What gets in the way of embracing creative, nonviolent solutions?
[16:46] The benefits of the protective use of force
[18:00] The importance of dropping enemy images
[20:34] How can I up level nonviolence in my own life?
[21:37] Outro

Are you transforming your relationship with force?  I’d love to know!  Leave a comment below.

Share this post

Dr. Yvette Erasmus is a clinical psychologist, author, and host of the podcast Conversations from the Heart. Through her integrated approach to personal transformation, she has built a global community, teaching people how to live into their values with courage and authenticity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

can I trust myself when I feel this much?
Inner Work & Discernment
#157 Can I Trust Myself When I Feel This Much?
When our emotions are intense and conflicting, it can feel impossible to know what’s true. This post explores why clarity disappears when we’re overwhelmed, and ...
Read more
how to stay open when you feel judged
Inner Work & Discernment
#156 How to Stay Open When You Feel Judged or ‘Fixed’
Why does “help” sometimes feel like criticism? In this post, we explore the nervous system response to being fixed, how old patterns of shutdown get ...
Read more
breaking the cycle without shame
Parenting & Family Life
#155 When You See Yourself in the Trigger: Breaking the Cycle Without Shame
What happens when the behavior that hurts you most is something you recognize in yourself? This post explores grandiosity, defensiveness, and how to break relational ...
Read more
the cost of being good
Inner Work & Discernment
#154 The Cost of Being “Good”: Breaking Patterns of Self-Abandonment
What do you do when someone you love can’t meet you in the way you need? We explores the shift from trying to change others ...
Read more

Unlock Your Free Intro Course with Dr. Yvette

Unlock powerful strategies that help you communicate with clarity, confidence, and genuine connection.

Intro Course Packets
6x