#149 Are You Regulating Yourself, or Silencing Yourself?

Are You Regulating Yourself or Silencing Yourself?
When we get good at regulating our emotions, we can sometimes lose touch with our voice. This post explores how to stay grounded without silencing what matters, and how to navigate anxiety, uncertainty, and discernment in early relationships.

There’s a moment in relational growth that doesn’t get talked about enough.

It’s the moment where all the inner work we’ve done starts to work against us.

We’ve learned how to regulate our emotions.

We’ve learned how to not overreact.

We’ve learned how to take responsibility for our inner world.

And then we find ourselves in a relationship and something feels off.

Not dramatically wrong or obviously harmful.

Just…not quite right.

A comment that lands a little sharp.

A pattern brings up discomfort.

There’s a sense of uncertainty we can’t quite settle, and instead of asking, Does this work for me?, we ask, How do I handle this better?

It begs the question, are you regulating yourself, or silencing yourself?

The Subtle Shift: From Regulation to Silence

Self-regulation is a powerful skill.

But when it becomes our default response to discomfort, it can quietly turn into self-silencing.

We talk ourselves out of our reactions or downplay what we feel. Perhaps we focus on understanding the other person and delay speaking what’s true.

These things happen not because we don’t care, but because we care so much.

Not Everything We Feel Is a Problem to Fix

One of the most important distinctions in relationships is knowing some feelings are signals and not symptoms.

  • Anxiety can come from uncertainty
  • Discomfort can point to misalignment
  • Emotional reactions can carry information about what matters to us

The work isn’t to eliminate these feelings. It’s to listen to them, without letting them take over.

The Practice of Gathering Data

In early relationships, we often feel pressure to decide quickly Is this right or wrong? Should I stay or go? Is this a red flag or am I overreacting?

But there’s another way to approach these questions.

Instead of deciding, gather data.

Have the conversation.

Name the impact.

Invite the other person into awareness.

And then watch. How do they respond? Are they open, defensive, curious? Does the dynamic shift or stay the same?

Discernment isn’t something we think our way into.

It’s something we experience over time.

Holding Compassion and Standards

A common trap, especially for thoughtful, empathetic people, is over-accommodation.

We see the other person’s intentions.

We understand their patterns.

We give them the benefit of the doubt.

And in doing so, we sometimes lose sight of ourselves.

Healthy relationships require both compassion for the other person and clarity about what works best for us

Not one at the expense of the other.

The Real Risk of Relationship

At some point, every meaningful relationship will ask something risky of us:

To be seen.

To be known.

To say what’s true before we know how it will be received.

And the deeper practice is not controlling the outcome, but trusting ourselves inside of it.

Turning Insight Into Action

Here are three ways to begin applying this:

1. Name What You’re Feeling Without Fixing It

Instead of trying to calm yourself immediately, try: Something in me feels uncomfortable right now.

Let the feeling exist before deciding what it means.

2. Separate Internal Work from Relational Data

Ask yourself: What’s happening inside of me? What am I learning about this person?

These are related, but not the same.

3. Practice One Honest Sentence

You don’t need a perfect script. Try something simple and real:

When that happened, I noticed I felt a little self-conscious.

Let that be enough to begin.

Are You Regulating Yourself or Silencing Yourself?

Growth isn’t just about becoming more regulated.

It’s about becoming more honest, more discerning, more anchored in yourself, while still remaining open to others.

Sometimes the most powerful question we can ask is: Am I caring for myself here, or quietly leaving myself out of the conversation?

Listen to the Full Conversation

Share this post

Dr. Yvette Erasmus is a clinical psychologist, author, and host of the podcast Conversations from the Heart. Through her integrated approach to personal transformation, she has built a global community, teaching people how to live into their values with courage and authenticity.

One Response

  1. Listening to the woman who mentioned that the person she has been dating for 3 months, has commented on her acne, has already defined what “normal” is, I would see these “red flags”. I would journal about it,= t see what triggers com up for me, discuss with a friend to get he feedback . I am sensitive about remarks about my physically for good reasons ( sexual molestation survivor). I do not think I would need to divulge that to my date, but I would say that i it does not feel to me good to comment on imperfections in each other’s bodies. My private thoughts would be ” Oh my. Now it is my acne, next year it will be my weight,” I might even tell him that women are told by the advertisement industry in cosmetics that the have to have perfect skin , eye lashes etc and that I find that regretful and very sad for teenagers growing up these days, so let;s role model differently. I would not attack myself with ” oh my looks is my issue I am taking this too personally.I would state that transcending a culture too focused on looks is an important value for me. I would wait to see how he responds , and have other conversations ( not on the same day) about what he would like or expect a woman to be before I would bring up ” shall we go steady and exclusive”. I;d check this guy out a bit longer . Gradually bring up things like” How do you define normal? Help me understand what the implications might be if you deem me not normal and I’d be disappointing you in what you would like it to look like? I’d have more such discussions because I am observing a pattern already. He is already attempting to mold and fix me to his liking, and i do not like it. After we talked enough I would know if he has an aha moment, and grows from what I shared with him, or not. If not, I might give him an honest reason why I do not want to forward because we are not a good match . Best to find out now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

learning to stay with ourselves
Inner Work & Discernment
#148 From Triggered to Sovereign: Learning to Stay With Ourselves in a Harsh World
A single moment, a tone of voice, a brief interaction, can completely shift our internal state. In this episode, we explore why small moments hit ...
Read more
care without carrying
Boundaries & Power
#147 How to Care Without Carrying: Sympathy, Compassion, and Emotional Boundaries
Understanding the difference between sympathy and compassion can transform our relationships. In this post, we explore how to care deeply without becoming overwhelmed, and how ...
Read more
How to stay kind without draining yourself
Relational Integrity
#146 How to Stay Kind Without Draining Yourself
Many of us have learned to equate kindness with availability, But over time, that equation can leave us feeling drained, resentful, and disconnected. In this ...
Read more
trying to be a better parent but still sounding critical
Parenting & Family Life
#145 Trying to Be a Better Parent, But Still Sounding Critical?
If you’ve ever found yourself thinking, I’m trying so hard to be a better parent… so why do I still sound critical?, you’re not alone. ...
Read more

Unlock Your Free Intro Course with Dr. Yvette

Unlock powerful strategies that help you communicate with clarity, confidence, and genuine connection.

Intro Course Packets
6x